It’s beginning to look like proper forests are natural aircon systems, and realising that could be a positive tipping point. Here’s how. 

people sitting on grass in city

In our age of spiralling climate concern, yet no sign of positive impact on observed climate heating, one barrier to effective action is that society does not currently perceive forests as climate infrastructure.

Urban planners already know they need reservoirs and a drainage system for water, an electricity grid for power, roads for transportation and parks for recreation. Many city planners have come to know of the benefit of having more trees for shade within urban areas, and to suck some pollutants out of the air. Currently, however, they don’t realise that cities can benefit from being adjacent to large forests, to benefit from their cloud-seeding and wind-generating effects. Discovering that a large forest can be important climate-modulating infrastructure, which could make hot cities more bearable, could transform the levels of support and finance for forest protection and regrowth. 

Currently, most advocacy and policy on forest conservation operates within one of four concerns, or frames: first there are livelihoods, landscape preservation and tourism; second, there is watershed protection, third there is biodiversity protection; and fourth, more recently, carbon sequestration. All are important, but have typically been sidelined when big business wants to mine the land, farm massively, or expand a city. In our era of climate disturbance, those four reasons for forest conservation don’t generate the same political and psychological urgency as recognising the following truth: forests are part of the natural climate infrastructure that keeps regions cool enough to be habitable.

There is a substantial and growing scientific basis for that view. Forests alter evapotranspiration, atmospheric moisture, cloud formation, surface energy fluxes and rainfall. Key is the way that pollen and bacteria from large forests seed clouds, both above them, and far beyond, thereby adding to the Earth’s reflectivity. Another mechanism is called the biotic pump, where large forests can draw in air from oceans and send the moisture and heat into the atmosphere, also creating clouds. 

Those processes combined seem to explain why, in tropical regions, deforestation has substantially disrupted regional rainfall and increased average and extreme temperatures.  One example is Borneo, where prior to 2018, researchers “found a strong island-wide relationship between forest loss and increases in daily temperature and reductions in daily precipitation.” The cascading effects of deforestation in Borneo on more recent droughts and fires is clear, with a devastating loss of wild habitat and dangerous transboundary pollution.

Recent climate research is increasingly emphasizing these ‘biohydrological’ processes, rather than treating forests simply as carbon stores. Worryingly, and unacceptably, this aspect of anthropogenic climate change continues to be marginalised through a narrow focus on atmospheric carbon. If this is new to you, please see my previous two essays on the matter (on the basics, and on some implications). I also recommend the work of Dr Anastassia Makarieva. 

As humanity is now a predominantly city-dwelling species, a key question within a heating world is not just whether some more tree-lined streets might help. It is whether some city-adjacent large natural forests could act as local and regional aircon systems. On this matter, there are various studies of cities in the tropics which indicate the cooling effects of forests, including studies which explain the specific processes involved in that, such as the generating of local winds. However, this subject has not yet received sufficient attention to document the process in policy-shaping detail. What would help is a comparative study of cities to identify differences in temperature averages and extremes in warm seasons. When adjusting for longitude, altitude, local typography, water body proximity, and urban size, such a study could provide valuable insight into the necessary size, proximity and maturity of a natural forest for it to seed clouds, drive winds, and transport heat. It is crucial work, and yet marginal to the mainstream climate agenda, and thus relatively underfunded.

Imagine if people and policy makers realised that large natural forests can be key for moderating excessive heat in their region? There could be a cascade of commitment to forest conservation around the world, involving city leadership, not just the national government departments focused on environment and land use. More people, in all walks of life, would begin to understand healthy ecosystems as key to maintaining their urban existence. 

Imagine if a hot tropical city, such as Kuala Lumpur, decided to experiment with a reforestation project in its hinterland, and assess the results over the next 20 years? Currently, much of the land to the west of the city is palm plantation, which does not deliver any of the cloud-seeding effects of a mature natural forest. Yet there are patches of official forest reserves, which could be connected, assisted and expanded. Such a project would either deliver, and confirm, the benefits of natural cloud seeding, or, if not, it would nevertheless become a useful resource, a beautiful one, along with its intrinsic worth. 

Imagine if more government officials became more aware of this role for forests. Regional and national planning processes could include large natural forests as key climate cooling infrastructure. As such, large natural forests could be regarded as being a far more valuable foundational asset than current ecosystem service assessments recognise. Such a realisation could re-invigorate cross border collaboration, including financial support, for conserving and restoring large forests in critical areas like Borneo. 

But there is a barrier to this potential being unleashed. It is a barrier found within the studies, reports, agendas and even minds of people working hard on climate change. It is that the climate-cooling value of large forests is conceptually invisible because “climate action” was reduced to greenhouse-gases. That leads to another barrier for massive forest conservation efforts: neither climate policy nor land use policy recognises the importance of forest-based climate modulation.

The absence of care for the climatic role of large forests doesn’t aid the smartness of policies on other issues, like food security. In some countries, including Indonesia, forests are being cleared to enable more agriculture. This is explained as necessary to combat increasing food insecurity in the face of climate change. However, forest clearance typically increases temperatures regionally, damaging existing agriculture, and thus worsening food insecurity.

Recognising the role of forests in climate modulation would also make it more difficult to justify forest clearance for mining the metals for an ‘energy transition’. That wouldn’t necessarily stop decisions which are, in any case, driven by profit and greed. However, at least it would remove the false fig leaf of environmental ‘concern’. 

The question before us is therefore how to overcome the barrier within climatology, and related climate policy, to unleash a ‘positive social tipping point’ in forest conservation for climate cooling. 

Here is where it is key to note that the recent years of global temperature changes are inexplicable according to past consensus in climatology. That presents a window of opportunity for a reassessment of the comprehensiveness of our understanding of anthropogenic climate change. In that context, ignoring a more pan-ecological approach to climate dynamics, including ‘biohydrological’ cycles, is no longer tenable. Moreover, dismissing anything other than a carbon-only understanding as giving space to resistance from fossil fuel interests, would be to allow those interests to have polluted the clarity of scientific assessment and its implications.

The climatologists who interface with other fields of science, such as the Earth Systems specialists, could be an influential node between different fields of expertise to spread awareness of this matter. Therefore, if a few senior leaders, key reports, and conferences, in the field of Earth Systems sciences, all communicated this understanding that large forests can act as natural aircon systems, it could bring the environmental professions to a threshold of awareness. 

One way forward is to create forest-climate demonstration and observation regions. In addition to major forest restoration activities, they would take measurements that explore connections between forest conditions and the heat, moisture, rainfall and water security in the region. They could also measure other potential beneficial impacts on air quality and on stable water flows. That would make the climate modulating functions of forests measurable, locally visible, and institutionally legible. If that demonstrated local climatic benefits, it would increase public demand and institutional investment. That would mean forest protection could move from being perceived as an environmental preference to being understood as a necessary form of climate infrastructure provision. As a result, forest protection efforts would start reproducing themselves socially in many locations around the world.

In an era of rapid climate change that is now damaging lives, not just landscapes, there is clear reason for a global wave of safe and nature-friendly experiments in natural climate modulation and adaptation. City leaders should not wait years for more research to confirm the specifics of size, proximity and maturity of a forest to achieve regional climate cooling effects. Instead, a ‘post-normal‘ approach to science is the wise one when stakes are high and delaying decisions has potentially massive and irreversible implications. It is an approach to climate science and policy that I outlined with Dr Rupert Read, in Chapter 1 of the book Deep Adaptation: Navigating the realities of climate chaos.

Once I became aware that large healthy forests can be key to reducing the increases in unpleasant and dangerous heat in some cities, while also seeding clouds regionally, I wanted to encourage more discussion about it. When I realised the potential power of city leaders in recognising that large forests can be essential climate infrastructure, I saw the need for this idea to be heard within the mainstream policy pow wows on climate change. That’s why I agreed for the co-founder of the Climate Cooling Initiative to pull me out of my rural life and efforts on deep adaptation, to return to the noise of big city conferencing. 

So I’m off to Kuala Lumpur to present at the Global Tipping Points conference. It’s the first time I’ve attended a climate conference since 2022 in Egypt, where Dr Ye Tao and I warned of accelerating climate change and the coming heat spike from reduced cloud cover. I’m hoping that some people attending our workshop will already know our premise, or be open to it, and come up with other, perhaps better, ideas for how to remove barriers to massive distributed action on natural climate cooling. I’ll let you know what happens, on jembendell.com. 

One way to share your views and efforts on this topic is within the Deep Adaptation and Metacrisis Leadership group on LinkedIn. It is moderated by the Metacrisis Initiative.

Communicating Collapse

talking scrabble letters on a wooden table

I don’t give many speeches or interviews on the topic of societal collapse. I find it tough. That’s because when speaking to audiences of mixed levels of awareness on social and environmental trends, I need to explain the latest data, convey the emotional weight of the conclusions, and provide some pointers on how to metabolise such feelings without either panic or aggressive dismissal. That process has never been a light one for me. First, I need to update myself on the latest data, in a way whether I synthesise and remember it well enough to be able to explain it. That’s no fun. Second, I need to allow the emotions to arise in me, as suppressing them might convey to people that this matter isn’t so important and upsetting. So that’s not much fun either. Third, some strong emotional reactions are normal, and present needs for follow-on engagement, across quite a spectrum. On the one hand, some people are deeply affected and request guidance. On the other hand, some people ‘shoot the messenger’ and frame me as problematic in some way. That can happen in small networks, or subsequently published ‘hit pieces’, which misrepresent my work and that of others who are ‘collapse aware’.  So what to do?

Recognising that ‘collapse communication’ comes with responsibilities, as well as taking an emotional toll on the communicator, is the reason why I participated over the years in various initiatives to support people to communicate kindly and wisely on this topic. As the troubles become more apparent, and new people talk about collapse, including some with great resources and reach to pitch their view of the world, now is not the time to be shy. If our intention is to slow and soften collapses, while creating possibilities for the future, without certainty, then we can try to learn how to communicate well and responsibly. That’s why ‘communicating collapse’ will be the topic of the next salon of the Metacrisis Initiative (sign up info follows at the end). 

This year I accepted invitations for a couple of interviews that would reach a wider audience than my existing following amongst the ‘collapse aware’. First, I was interviewed for a climate-engaged audience, on the podcast of the MEER initiative. It is promoting local initiatives at reflecting the sun’s rays, to achieve some local cooling. In the interview, I covered some of the claims in the 2018 Deep Adaptation paper that are confirmed by recent data or science, before explaining how scientists on climate could avoid new kinds of mistakes today. In particular, I emphasised the need to look beyond atmospheric carbon to natural cloud seeding processes for an understanding of recent heating. That’s a view with massive implications for environmental activism and policy, if only scientists could convey that wider – panecological – understanding of the biophysical drivers of the climate crisis. 

The next interview released on video was with Finn Harries, for his new podcast ‘The Seeds Will Grow’. Originally, Finn became well known with his twin brother as a teen youtuber, and then progressed into environmental communications. On the podcast he explains the impact that the Deep Adaptation paper had on him, which led to his focus on regenerative projects, including Juntos Farm. For such a specialist conversation, it has already received a lot of engagement, and the comments on the video are like a mini-forum of ideas (awaiting your own contribution!).

For three years, I hosted a guest every month to discuss aspects of our responses to societal collapse. The interviews remain an important resource for people new to this topic, or exploring new aspects of it. Guests included Joanna Macy, Charles Eisenstein, Gail Bradbrook and Vanessa Andreotti. I am considering hosting interviews again, and trialled that with Kin Thao, who is the network coordinator for the Oceanic and Asian region of the Global Ecovillage Network. She was in Indonesia as part of the networking and exchange of ideas that I helped to fund. If you are interested in how intentional communities, of any size or type, can be catalysts for change in an era of metacrisis and collapse, then I recommend the interview. It was the first time I’ve ever sung with an interviewee!

Rather than public advocacy or education, my main focus will remain the Metacrisis Initiative, where we help the ‘collapse aware’ to live purposefully. The deadline to join the second cohort of peer mentoring is in early October 2026. That means you need to be a member before then to be able to join a mentoring group from November. If you are a young professional (under 35), or from the ‘Global South’, or have limited means, please request free membership here. Otherwise, it is $8 a month. 

“I keep meeting people who lack a community to discuss societal collapse. We need healthy spaces to discuss our response. That’s why I participate in the Metacrisis Initiative.” Josie McLean, PhD, Co-founder, Climate Coaching Alliance

“The peer mentoring has created a tight bond with people who were strangers at first, around this sometimes heavy subject. It’s an opportunity for me to connect with my feelings, whilst not being overwhelmed by them.” Bibi Gratzer, Sacred Union Podcast. 

Join the Metacrisis Initiative for salons and mentoring

Deadlines for mentoring are coming soon.

Blinded by The Light (newspaper)

As with many countries in the Western world, the UK has seen a rise of ethno-nationalist politics in recent years. One politician who led the Brexit agenda to leave the EU, is Nigel Farage. Not being able to blame the Eurocrats anymore, the lie took hold that Britain’s ills could be blamed on poor immigrants rather than greedy elites. Recently, Farage has come under fire for his alleged expressions of antisemitism. Although that focused on his childhood, his appearances on the podcast of alt-right conspiracy theorist Alex Jones was also discussed. During an appearance, Farage claimed that ‘globalists’ are trying to override national sovereignty by creating one world government. Some critics have claimed that it was ‘dogwhistling’ about threats from Jewish elites. The concern arises because Jones and Farage claim there are evil cabals of people, rather than members of a transnational capitalist class, who are serving the extractive demands of international capital. They don’t discuss capitalism in an intelligent way, because then they would be criticising their friends, funders, and the system that has promoted their views to huge audiences. Discussions in the mass media about who ‘globalists’ are and whether we should be concerned about them (and the structures of capital they serve) could be welcomed, if those discussions go beyond the lazy and nasty tropes of antisemitism. Unfortunately, such discussions seem difficult to have in the UK and elsewhere, as political discussion is often febrile and superficial. I was reminded of that recently in the town of Stroud, where one independent newspaper seems to have generated new debates and fractures between people who previously worked together for social change. In this essay, I want to share what I noticed from reading that newspaper and from experiencing the community fractures that emerge around its arguments. If the mass media weren’t so badly misinforming people in order to protect elites, perhaps this situation would not be so difficult. But in such a poor information system, there is work to get people talking about what can be done together at community level as life gets increasingly difficult for so many.  

Continue reading “Blinded by The Light (newspaper)” →

The Mirage of Climate Action at the Summit in Brazil

In this era of societal disruption and metacrisis, international climate summits provide us a Shakespearean display of the human craving for credible myths to avoid daunting truths. Four lanes of greed carve through one of the remaining lungs and heat-shields of our planet — and this month it speeds 50,000 souls towards reassuring each other that they are noble, not needy, and well-informed, not foolish. Earlier this year, the summit secretariat rushed to tell everyone that this new highway through the Amazon Rainforest would have been built anyway. They’d probably heard how new roads cause – and then enable – deforestation. The Brazilian government responded with some more commitments on rainforest protection. That’s promising, but they still give permits to dig up the Amazon for the metals under the trees. The mirage shimmering above the asphalt, seen by delegates as they approach the city of Belem, is a symbol for what passes as scientific curiosity, environmental care, and responsible leadership on the world stage in 2025. 

Ahead of the latest tropical junket, I spoke with the Climate Emergency Forum about what the climate has been telling us through the crazy temperature readings over the last two years. The changes can’t be explained through carbon gases alone. There are various contributing factors — and an important one is that human activity has badly disrupted the biohydrological processes where large forests and oceans naturally seed clouds. I explained the need for a paradigm shift in climatology and related activism and policy, and mentioned my recent essay on the topic, where I summarise the evidence. As many people have followed my analysis on the topic since 2018, I thought it important to summarise my latest understanding — beyond ‘carbon-centrism’.

Continue reading “The Mirage of Climate Action at the Summit in Brazil” →

Centering Citizen Ownership: Britain is not for sale and Palestine is not for stealing.

The transcript of a speech delivered in Stroud, UK on 13th Sept 2025, by Professor Jem Bendell.

“Britain’s not for sale and Palestine’s not for stealing – defending and restoring citizenship ownership in the face of collapse.”

I am pleased to be back in ‘The People’s Republic of Stroud’. I first saw that phrase in the background of a talk entitled ‘heading for extinction’ by Gail Bradbrook back in 2018. People in the town of Stroud played a key role in the formation and growth of Extinction Rebellion, which sparked a new wave of environmentalism, bringing wider attention to the climate crisis. I mention that today, as I’m interested in connections between more commonly-owned assets, on the one hand, and a political voice on the other. Only with both of those do we increase the chances of coping better with a creeping collapse of the systems and opportunities we once had.

Today is unusual for me, as I am going to talk about politics. I have never given a speech before that is explicitly about politics. In the first half of 2017, I worked in front line politics with Jeremy Corbyn and his team. I advised on strategic communication, co-wrote speeches, and some of the manifesto. I went on to train some of the current backroom staff for PM Keir Starmer, including Morgan McSweeney. But I have never given a political speech myself. I feel now is the time to do that, because of what’s happening in Britain right now.

Continue reading “Centering Citizen Ownership: Britain is not for sale and Palestine is not for stealing.” →

Here’s how we get serious about the awful monetary system

I have been hearing more of my environmentalist friends mention that the monetary and banking systems are driving a metacrisis, where nearly everything is getting worse, nearly everywhere. Like me, they have come to realise that by incentivising endless commodification, debt, and growth, an expansionist monetary system is at the root of so much of what’s going wrong. But most of them are at a loss for what to do about it. Why? Because it’s big, vague, and hard to understand. In my case, it took years of study to feel that I could speak clearly on the subject – finally taking to the TEDx stage in 2011. In the years since then, I met many environmentalists who were so overwhelmed by the topic that they went back to what was familiar to them: fighting plastics, pushing for stricter deforestation laws, or calling for lower carbon footprints. All are important. But if we ignore the expansionist monetary system that drives such harms, amongst others, our situation will only get worse. That’s why it is important that more of us do the ‘hard yards’ in learning about the nature of current monetary systems, what the alternatives are, and how to enable them. That is important, whatever our current assessment on the pace of societal disruption and collapse; although a breaking of old systems can create space for the alternatives. 

The mainstream still needs to wake up to money 

Today, when I look at leading green groups like WWF, Greenpeace, Friends of the Earth, I see that they are still focusing on what we did 20 years ago when I was head of the ‘markets and economic governance’ team at WWF-UK. For instance, they continue to criticise bank loans to oil or mining companies, but rarely mention how money itself is created. 

Continue reading “Here’s how we get serious about the awful monetary system” →

Why Isn’t Organic the Norm in Bali?

The Ubud Food Festival concluded yesterday here in Bali, Indonesia. I spoke at an event on how to work better with nature to achieve greater food security. I was invited due to my co-founding of an organic farm school, and was pleased to attend as we encourage collaboration amongst restaurants to scale up organic farming. Our crowdfund to help with that is still a few thousand short of the necessary target. In preparation for the event, I drafted some notes on what I’d say. They follow below. If you can support us, please take a moment to contribute. Thx, Jem

—

It’s a pleasure to be here with you in Ubud — a town that’s become an international symbol of nature-based spirituality, conscious living, and the pursuit of wellness. 

Let me start with a question: How many of you would prefer to eat organic food, that’s food grown without any chemicals? And now — how many of you know that you always eat organic food here in Bali?

Continue reading “Why Isn’t Organic the Norm in Bali?” →

The Magic of the Metacrisis

The following is a talk I gave to open the 2nd Alumni Gathering for the course ‘Leading Through Collapse.’ After 7 years we ended teaching the course, but invited the 300+ alumni to gather. The talk is available as a video, and transcript. I touch on some issues about how to remain outward in our focus, and the importance of thinking about what terms might help engage people in the transformative opportunities of accepting our predicament. Thx for watching or reading! Jem

Subscribe / Support / Study / Essays

May 9th 2025, from Indonesia

Collapse is undeniably painful, especially for those directly affected, and it’s difficult to witness when it unfolds. However, within this process, there are spaces of possibility that arise when we stop denying the reality of our situation. A collapse of systems, while disorienting, also makes room for transformation.

In our relative privilege, many of us have been shy to speak about any of these upsides to what is otherwise a tragic situation. But I have come to realise that there could be a benefit for others, not just ourselves, if we are more open about those upsides. Because the way we are transformed can make us more open to others, and help people to recognise that there can be positive ways to live in this era of collapse.

Continue reading “The Magic of the Metacrisis” →

How People Get Ready – building the commons in working-class communities is key to collapse preparation.

The one talk that I’m scheduled to give in the UK this year is at the Festival of Commoning in Stroud. My reason for that is my support of what Michel Bauwens describes as cosmolocalism [0] in the face of collapse, and what I term the ‘Great Reclamation’ of our power. It is best explained and illustrated by one of the organisers of the Festival, Dave Darby, in a guest article…

“All civilisations collapse in the end. The Roman Empire is long gone, along with the ancient Greeks, Egyptians and Sumerians. Will the global civilisation of corporate capitalism buck the trend? Of course not, but how long does it have left? In such a complex system, it is impossible to predict when there will be a sudden shift, but there is good evidence that the process of breakdown has already begun. Damage to soils, water tables, forests, the oceans and climate is occurring alongside economic and political upheaval. No longer is this a theoretical matter about the distant future, but something we should be preparing for today. But how? 

Continue reading “How People Get Ready – building the commons in working-class communities is key to collapse preparation.” →

Holding Space for Strong Emotions

“I wanted to punch the guy, but when I realised I couldn’t do that, I just switched off.”

This was certainly a new kind of response to giving a speech. I’d just left the stage at a conference on adaptation to climate change, and was surrounded by people wanting to exchange a few words and contact details. “You really stimulated the audience, as we hoped you would,” one of the organisers said, smiling as he told me of the guy who liked my views so much that he wanted me to connect with his knuckles.

I’d already heard enthusiastic praise from another organiser, so I reacted to the negative feedback in dismissive fashion. “Anger is a way of responding to difficult information, situations and emotions. It gets us out of fear,” is more or less what I said. I continued with my mini lecture by saying “Fight or freeze are two normal responses to fear. It’s why I talked about the benefit of getting better with allowing, witnessing and working through difficult emotions. It’s also why we must recognise so much of our conversation in professional circles is to avoid conflict and emotional difficulty, using convenient narratives, that stop us from facing reality.” This all tripped off my tongue because being intellectual and slightly combative is my go-to response when under threat. However, I’m writing this essay because I was on the cusp of noticing that go-to response, and chose a different way to engage when experiencing conflict. If you also navigate strong emotions about the state of our world, I hope the following thoughts may be of use.

Continue reading “Holding Space for Strong Emotions” →